Discovery

Challenging Assumptions about Balance Transfer

I started by looking at how balance transfers are typically used—primarily for debt consolidation, where customers move existing credit card debt to a lower APR to make repayment more manageable.

Balance Transfer Card Member Strong internal demand

To unpack where confusion was coming from, I compared Balance Transfer, Balance Transfer into Checking, and Cash Advance—revealing overlapping benefits and unclear distinctions that were not well communicated to customers.

Balance Transfer product comparison table

Reviewing old BT Enrollment Flow

UX Review: The web enrollment flow appeared simple, but key offer details weren’t clearly surfaced. Multiple options created decision friction.

The web enrollment flow appeared simple, but key offer details weren’t clearly surfaced. Multiple options created decision friction.

Strategy

Because hesitation stemmed from both enrollment friction and liquidity confusion, we needed two streams of work. I led a dual-track design approach, balancing near-term UX uplifts with longer-term revenue growth.

Dual-track design strategy overview

1. Optimize - BT Enrollment Flow

Hypothesis: Leveraging the proven mobile pattern will increase BT request completion.

Pros - More focus on a task, replicating effective mobile patterns on web | Cons - Multiple pages

Hypothesis: Leveraging the proven mobile pattern will increase BT completion.

Utilizing Discover design system web components, I generated the optimized flow diagram

Point & click to zoom-in on the optimized Balance Transfer request flow chart.

2A. Intent-based Framing Design

Hypothesis: Clear, intent-based framing helps drive BIC adoption and stronger BT engagement.

Pros - Makes selection feel intuitive and purpose-driven | Cons - May slow regular BT users

Hypothesis: Clear, intent-based framing helps drive BIC adoption and stronger BT engagement. Hypothesis: Clear, intent-based framing helps drive BIC adoption and stronger BT engagement.

2B. Success-Moment Introduction

Hypothesis: BIC engagement increases when introduced after BT completion.

Pros - Leverages positive momentum after completion, opportunity for contextual education
Cons - Reduced urgency compared to pre-enrollment framing

Hypothesis: Leveraging the proven mobile pattern will increase BT completion. Hypothesis: Leveraging the proven mobile pattern will increase BT completion.

Solution

The implemented version

We chose intent-framing upfront to clarify the transfer before commitment.

We chose intent-framing upfront to clarify the transfer before commitment.

Impact

Impact summary showing reduced enrollment hesitation and increased confidence Project reflection including lessons learned and future testing opportunities

Next case study